Uterine Fibroids Blog — An Expert Speaks Out

Real Women, Real Stories, Real Answers

by Paul Indman, MD

Why diagnosis is so important: Submucous uterine fibroid

Author: Paul Indman, M.D. 20.12.2010

A 43 year old woman came to me with irregular bleeding despite being on birth control pills.  Her OB/GYN had inserted a Mirena® IUD 7 months ago, which failed to stop her irregular bleeding. During her first visit with me I did a vaginal ultrasound, which showed an almond size fibroid in the uterine cavity.   We did an office hysteroscopy, and saw the IUD resting on the fibroid.

Mirena IUD with Fibroid
Mirena IUD next submucous fibroid

The IUD was removed.   Since she was not planning any more children, we removed the fibroid by hysteroscopic myomectomy, and did an endometrial ablation at the same time as an outpatient procedure.

Comment:   The Mirena®  IUD (LNG-IUS) is often effective in treating heavy periods, but a fibroid inside the cavity can interfere. I always recommend doing a simple ultrasound exam in women with abnormal bleeding before deciding on a treatment.  Other studies such as diagnostic hysteroscopy may also be done, as only with proper diagnosis can appropriate treatment be planned. In her situation a simple outpatient procedure was able to solve her bleeding problem.


Dr. Indman performed two procedures for me at the same time – a hysteroscopic myomectomy and an endometrial ablation. From the pre-op to post surgery, I did not experience any pain or a single cramp. I was back to work the next day and back on my regular workout schedule within two weeks. After three weeks, I went on a cycling vacation and rode 350+ miles over hilly terrain. I felt great! Without the surgery, there was no possible way I could have done this. For the first time in 1 1/2 years, I am not experiencing heavy bleeding and checking where the nearest bathrooms are.

My experience with Dr. Indman and his staff have been nothing short of fantastic. Dr. Indman is a warm, caring, highly skilled surgeon – with a fun sense of humor to boot! He is one of those rare gems in the medical profession today – someone who truly puts patients first. I found Dr. Indman while researching my symptoms on the Internet. The wealth of helpful information on his website gave me a lot of confidence even before I met him. His deep expertise and decades of experience are evident from his thorough examinations and explanations.  — S.K.

Comment:  S.K. had a submucous fibroid, which was treated by hysteroscopic myomectomy and endometrial ablation as an outpatient.  Here are actual pictures from her surgery.  The first shows the fibroid on the right side of the uterus, with the loop that will be used to remove it.  The second shows the fibroid having been removed, and the third is after endometrial ablation.  I do the endometrial ablation under direct vision to be sure that no areas are missed.

Submucous uterine fiboid picture

It is not unusual for women to resume most normal activities within a day or two.  Careful patient selection and utmost skill are required for a safe and successful procedure. — Paul Indman, M.D.

Update:  12/14/2010: S.K. came in for a 4 month check after her procedure, having recently run a marathon.   She said that she kept thinking that without the surgery running a marathon would have been impossible.


Submucous fibroid on bottom left, roller ball on rightMarch 9, 2010 a 46 year old woman came to me having been told that she needs a hysterectomy because of heavy bleeding from her fibroid. She wanted to know her options.  Ultrasound showed a tennis ball size fibroid that was 2/3 in the uterine wall and 1/3 in the cavity of the uterus. We confirmed the ultrasound by doing an office hysteroscopy, where we could see the fibroid protruding into the cavity. Read on to learn about her options and see photographs of her treatment. Read the rest of this entry »


Uterine Fibroids, Infertility, and Pregnancy

Author: Paul Indman, M.D. 19.05.2010

Should I have my fibroids removed before I try to get pregnant?  That is one of the most difficult questions I have to answer!  Here is what we know:

  1. Types of Uterine Fibroids — LocationSubmucous fibroids, or intramural fibroids that indent the endometrial cavity (inside of the uterus) significantly decrease the chances of conception, and increase the miscarriage rate. Large intramural fibroids (in the wall of the uterus) can have a submucous portion that distorts the cavity and should be considered included in this group.  Fibroids that are mostly in the endometrial cavity can usually be removed by outpatient hysteroscopic myomectomy (hysteroscopic resection).  This should only be done by a gynecologist with extensive experience in hysteroscopic surgery to reduce the risk of  scar tissue formation.  Although it may be possible to remove some submucous fibroids that are mostly in the wall hysteroscopically, if they are large they should be removed by abdominal, laparoscopic, or robotic myomectomy.
  2. Intramural fibroids that do not indent the cavity appear to decrease fertility and increase miscarriage rates, but studies are inconclusive. Even if this is the case, studies are lacking to show that removing these fibroids increases the chance of successful pregnancy.
  3. There is no evidence that subserous fibroids interfere with conception or increase the miscarriage rate.

Fibroids in Pregnancy

Although we used to think that pregnancy causes fibroids to increase in size, ultrasound studies show that they usually do not grow.  They often feel larger because the whole uterus is larger.

Some of the problems fibroids can cause are:

  1. Pain, which can be severe enough to require hospitalization.  Sometimes a fibroid may infarct or cause pain because of decreased blood flow.
  2. Increased risk of placenta problems such as abruption (premature separation of the placenta).
  3. Increased risk of prematurity.
  4. Increased risk of cesarean section.
  5. Increased risk for post-partum hemorrhage.

The risks of serious complication are low.  Most women with fibroids go through pregnancy without any problems.

Treatment recommendation for fibroids before attempting pregnancy


There is no way I or any other physician can make specific recommendations without evaluating you individually!  These are general recommendations, and should not be followed without advice from your own physician.

If fibroids are causing symptoms such as heavy bleeding, pain or pressure it is usually reasonable to remove themIf the fibroids are not causing symptoms, the following are general recommendations.

1.  Most submucous fibroids should be removedHysteroscopic myomectomy, when done by an expert, is the treatment of choice in most situations.

2. Intramural fibroids that distort the endometrial cavity should usually be removed before attempting pregnancy.

3.  Intramural myomas that do not distort the endometrial cavity and are not causing symptoms usually do not need to be removed before attempting pregnancy.  There is no evidence that removing them improves pregnancy outcomes.

4.  Subserous myomas, unless large enough to cause symptoms, do not need to be removed prior to pregnancy.

Is myomectomy risky? This obviously depends on the skill of the surgeon.  The risk of needing to do a hysterectomy at the time should be less than 1 in 100.  I have never had to do an unplanned hysterectomy in a woman of reproductive age when I had planned to do a myomectomy.  While adhesions can develop, there are a techniques to minimize them.  All in all, myomectomy should not lower, and in many cases will improve the chances for a successful pregnancy.  Be aware that if many or deep fibroids are removed (except by hysteroscopic myomectomy) a cesarean delivery will often be recommended.

What about other treatments, such as embolization (UAE or UFE)?  Embolization blocks the blood vessels to the fibroids and/or uterus.  Although new blood vessels my take over to supply the uterus, the effect on pregnancy is unknown.  While there have been successful pregnancies after embolization, it also can decrease ovarian reserve or menopause as well as causing intrauterine adhesions (Asherman’s syndrome).  Therefore I, and most experts in fertility, would only recommend embolization as a last resort in women desiring pregnancy.


If you’re reading this, you’re probably suffering with issues related to uterine fibroids (heavy bleeding, cramping, Anemia, fertility issues, etc.). I’m writing this because I used to struggle with those same health issues. Today, I’m back to living a normal life, even though I never thought it would be possible again.

Read the rest of this entry »


Hysteroscopic Myomectomy with Resectoscope

Change this caption

Uterine fibroids that are completely or partially inside the cavity of the uterus (submucous myomas) can often be removed through the cervix by using an instrument called a resectoscope. A resectoscope is a special kind of hysteroscope that uses a loop powered by high-frequency electrical energy to cut through the fibroid.  Since the instrument goes through the cervix, no incision is necessary.  This is usually done as an outpatient, and recovery typically requires a day or two until most normal activity can be resumed.

Selection of patients for whom hysteroscopic removal of fibroids is appropriate is one of the most important factors in obtaining good results. Factors to consider are the size and number of fibroids, location, the percentage that is in the cavity and percentage that is in the wall (intramural) or the uterus, the possibility that other intramural or subserous myomas would remain, and the desire for future pregnancy are some of the factors that must be considered.

Fibroids that are entirely inside the uterine cavity are the easiest to resect, and a very experienced gynecologist may be able to resect these up to 5 cm. (2 inches) in diameter.  Most submucous fibroids are partially in the wall of the uterus.  The illustration above shows a fibroid that is about 2/3 in the cavity and 1/3 in the wall.  During the process of resecting this the uterus often contracts, squeezing out the portion that is in the wall, and allowing more complete removal.

The photo below shows a large fibroid that is over 50% in the wall, as determined by MRI.  This is the most difficult type of fibroid to remove hysteroscopically, especially if it is toward the top of the uterus.

Submucous Uterine Fibroid over 50% intramural

The loop is used to resect the fibroid, bite by bite, (photo on the left) until it is level with the surface.  In this case a special medication was used to help the uterus contract so virtually all of the fibroid could be squeezed into the cavity,  allowing me to completely remove it.  The right photo shows the “shell” of where the myoma was.  This will cover over with endometrium (the lining of the uterus).  When we look at this area in several months with office hysteroscopy we won’t even be able to see where the fibroid used to be.

Hysteroscopic Resection of Fibroid — BeginningHysteroscopic Resection of Fibroid Finished

Comment:  This last example pushes the limits of hysteroscopic myomectomy. This woman ended up with a normal uterine cavity, with no adhesions (scar tissue).  When this type of procedure is considered in a woman wanting to become pregnant,  much experience is needed to determine whether hysteroscopic treatment will leave a normal cavity or will cause permanent scarring and infertility.  Hysteroscopic removal of all but the simplest submucous fibroids should only be done by a gynecologist with extensive experience in hysteroscopic surgery. I will have more about hysteroscpic myomectomy in time to come.


Treatment Options for Uterine Fibroids

Author: Paul Indman, M.D. 05.04.2010

Uterine Fibroids can effect quality of life, can at times cause dangerous problems such as severe hemorrhage, but most often cause no problems at all.  The first question to ask is should fibroids be treated rather than how.

Fibroids should be treated if they cause heavy bleeding resulting in anemia that can’t be controlled with iron and medicines.  Fibroids that prolapse (protrude) through the cervix often cause heavy bleeding, pain, and can become infected.  Certain types of fibroids can cause infertility or difficulty in pregnancy.  These fibroids should be treated.

I like to draw analogies.  Imagine you have a car and the brakes don’t work.  If you don’t fix them immediately bad things will happen!

Many fibroids are so small that a woman is unaware that she has them, or cause only minimal symptoms.  These can be watched by a gynecologist and many never require any treatment.

The decision of when and how to treat fibroids that interfere with the quality of life without actually presenting a major health hazard can be difficult.  Let me present  two examples of such problems that can be caused by fibroids:

  • Joan notices that it is difficult to fit in her clothes because her fibroids make her look like she is 5 months pregnant.  She has to urinate frequently, and is bothered by the pressure.
  • Kristine is a teacher, and has periods so heavy that she is afraid she’ll soak through her clothes several days a month.  She frequently bleeds between periods, and finds it difficult to plan vacations because of her bleeding.  She takes iron, so her blood count is normal.

Let’s get back to the car analogy.  Let’s say the heater and air conditioner don’t work and the windows are stuck down in a town where it’s zero degrees in the winter and 105 in the summer.  When does the car need to be fixed?  When you are tired of freezing or roasting.   But it’s not like driving without brakes, as it’s a matter of comfort rather than safety.  The decision is not that different than deciding when to treat fibroids.  When they interfere with your ability to do what you want to do you should consider treatment.

It’s important to remember that fibroids often grow until menopause, and then usually decrease in size.  A woman who is 30 has many year until menopause, and it is likely that if she is bothered by fibroids it will only get worse over the years.  On the other hand a woman who is 49 would be expected to reach menopause soon, and if there are ways to control her symptoms from the fibroids there is a reasonable chance that they may improve after menopause.

Once the decision is made that fibroids should be treated, the next question is how.  There are many different procedures, each claiming to be the greatest and the best.  While I will be writing about many methods of fibroid treatments in detail, it is far less confusing if you realize that all of the methods fall into four basic categories:

  1. Medical treatment of fibroids.  While there are no medicines that cure fibroids, there are medicines that may control symptoms and result in a temporary decrease in size.
  2. Destroy the fibroids.  These methods leave the fibroids in place, but attempt to kill them by cutting off their blood supply, or using electrical, thermal, or ultrasound energy to “cook” them.  The body then absorbs the dead tissue.
  3. Take out the fibroids.  Depending on size and location, fibroids may be removed through an incision, a laparoscope or robot, or through the cervix (hysteroscopically).  Once the fibroids are gone they do not grow back, but new fibroids can grow.
  4. Take out the uterus.  This guarantees that the fibroids are gone forever.  There are some situations where this is the best option and many in which it is unacceptable.  More about this in the oncoming months.

Another factor in planning treatment is the desire for future pregnancy.  I’ll talk about fibroids and pregnancy in the future, but obviously a hysterectomy is out of the question for someone who wants to have a baby.  I have serious reservations about any of the destructive procedures, such as embolization (UFE) if future pregnancy is desired.  If we are going to remove the fibroids then we need to consider which procedure is most likely to leave a normal uterus.

Lastly, preference is definitely important.  Back to the car analogy…. If  you tell me you want a red car because red cars are faster than blue cars we can do an experiment and race them.  But if you tell me you want a red car because you hate blue, it is a matter of personal preference.  I see many women for myomectomy that could be appropriately treated by other methods such as embolization or hysterectomy, but they don’t like the idea of losing their uterus and don’t want foreign particles in their body.  My job is to inform them of the advantages and disadvantages of each of these choices, and help them decide which treatment best suits their lifestyle and personal beliefs.

The most important thing to realize is that you can not make a decision  about which treatment is most appropriate just by reading!!! A 3 cm. (1+ inch) fibroid that is inside the cavity of the uterus and causing heavy periods is almost always best treated by hysteroscopic resection, a quick outpatient procedure.  If the same size fibroid is mostly in the wall the treatment may be different, or it may not need to be treated at all.  While it is good to learn as much as you can by reading an appropriate treatment plan can only be reached after an accurate diagnosis. Unfortunately there are varying abilities to make an accurate diagnosis.  I find reading an ultrasound report much like reading a movie review in the newspaper.  Sometimes it’s right on and sometimes you can’t believe it’s the same movie.  I  see women who have been told they have fibroids turn out to have adenomyosis or at times ovarian cysts, or even nothing at all.  While it is good to learn about different treatment methods, you need the help of a gynecologist knowledgable about all options to help you decide what is best for your individual situation.